Zambian government launches new five-year AIDS strategy

The new National HIV and AIDS Strategic Framework (NASF, 2006-2010) was presented this week to a meeting of key government, UN and donor stakeholders and a few members of civil society organizations by the Zambian Minister of Health, Angela Cifire. In a country with an HIV prevalence rate ranging from 8% in Northern Province to 22% in the capital, Lusaka, where women are about 1.4 times more likely to be HIV-infected than men, and where and estimated 7.7% of young people aged 15-24 are thought to be living with HIV, the new strategy is vital and much welcomed.

The vision of the multi-sectoral response outlined in the new framework is a nation free from the threat of HIV. It aims for a "multisectoral response, coordinated by the National AIDS Council (NAC) that is committed to controlling HIV and AIDS by integrating the epidemic into the work of every partner and the development agenda."

The NAC has identified six key areas for intervention. According to the new framework, scaled-up actions will be rapid and responsive to the needs of the local communities. Within each key theme, the document describes the strategic objective, the rationale and challenges, as well as detailed strategies for achieving the targets. The six key areas are:

    * Intensifying prevention of HIV transmission;
    * Expanding treatment, care and support for people living with and affected by HIV;
    * Mitigating the socio-economic impact of HIV;
    * Strengthening the decentralized response by mainstreaming HIV;
    * Improving the capacity for monitoring by all partners;
    * Integrating advocacy and coordination of the multi-sectoral response.

The NASF includes a review of progress from 2002-2005 against current targets and indicators, as well as a summary of the political, economic, socio/cultural and technological factors that underpin the epidemic and the response.

Following the presentation, Dr Deji Popoola, Chairperson of the UN Theme Group on HIV and AIDS in Zambia, also outlined the workplan of the United Nations Country Team in Zambia (2007-2010). According to Dr Popoola, all UN organizations in Zambia will work from one workplan for the coming years. The workplan outlines the overall UN support to the national AIDS response and has strategically prioritized the tasks of the NASF, as they most closely align with the respective strengths of the 13 UN organizations present in the country.

Under the same six thematic areas outlined above, the UN Country Team expect the following outcomes as a result of their combined support:

    * An effective NAC that is able to achieve its mandate;
    * Increased access to an effective and comprehensive package of HIV prevention services, based on approaches that address the underlying drivers of the epidemic;
    * Increased access to treatment, care and support services;
    * Strengthened institutional capacity to mitigate the socio-economic impact for people infected and affected by HIV.

In support of these four outcomes, 16 corresponding outputs and 2007 results and activities are also defined. This adds up, at least on paper, to a coordinated, harmonized and carefully planned UN response to HIV in Zambia.

It was then the donors' turn to present their vision and commitments in support of the NASF. A presentation by the US government representative outlined the priority areas for support. They were unfortunately unable at this time to pledge specific financial commitments until they are approved by the US administration. The areas of support mentioned were: Public-private partnership, expanding coverage of programmes to prevent mother-to-child transmission of HIV (PMTCT) , more resources for antiretroviral (ARV) drug provision, greater focus on paediatric ARV formulations, increased support to orphans and other vulnerable children, support to the civil society response by assisting with organizational development, finance skills etc, and finally, direct funding to the NAC and line ministries on workplace policies. The US government also mentioned their intention to join the national 'Joint Financing Arrangement' (JFA) in 2007.

"We really appreciate increased direct support to the NAC - it will go a long way" said Sam Kapembwa of Zambia National AIDS Network (ZNAN).

On behalf of donors in the Joint Financing Arrangement (JFA), which currently includes the governments of Norway, Ireland, Sweden, the Netherlands and the United Kingdom, Beverly Warmington, Head of the UK Department for International Development in Zambia, also addressed the meeting. Instead of presenting a programme of work, she reinforced the principle of the JFA: To provide flexible and predictable funding to the NAC in order to enable it to undertake its fundamental role in coordinating the HIV response in Zambia ('One Coordinating Body'). She emphasized the need for more donors to join the JFA in support of NAC. In 2006 the total resources allocated to the NAC was approximately $4 million compared with the total Zambian HIV resources of $272 million for the same year. Acknowledging the US government's signal that they will join the JFA in their 2007 country plan, Dr Warmington urged others to join. A new JFA 'cycle' is due to commence this July.

Conspicuously absent from the roster of invited speakers was a representative of civil society or affected communities. There was no presentation on what civil society intends to achieve over the next five years. Rosemary Kumwenda, Assistant UN Resident Representative and HIV & Poverty Adviser, commented after the meeting "the voice of civil society is missing"

Paul Zulu, founder of Human Rights Foundation in Lusaka commented, "It is a good beginning - work has started and now we need to make sure it is implemented."

The Minister opened the floor for comments, but was met with a resounding silence all round - not one civil society representative felt able to speak up in the meeting.

While the NASF, the Joint UN Programme of Support and the donors had presented their strategic visions for the next five years, civil society's voice was missing. A key challenge will be to ensure that civil society is integrated and working alongside other key stakeholders as each has a key role to play. An essential step towards this would be to have a representative from civil society reporting as part of future HIV Partnership Forum meetings.

"Everything is in writing now. Money needs to be made available for organizations that are dealing with the drivers of the epidemic," commented Miriam Banda of the National Zambian Network of People Living with HIV/AIDS (NZP+). "We need to make sure there is a lot of emphasis on the socio-economic impact".

Ms Banda also remarked on the absence of emphasis on tuberculosis (TB) in the presentation of the plans.

"It is a big oversight. HIV and TB co-infection needs to be treated together".

In the NASF document, TB is mentioned in one paragraph under the theme of expanding treatment, care and support. In terms of strategies and outputs, it is combined with other sexually-transmitted infections and opportunistic infections (OI). In a country where up to 70% of TB patients are co-infected with HIV, and where more than 50% of people living with HIV will develop TB in their life time, TB has clearly not been emphasized enough and was completely absent from today's meeting.

The meeting ended with asense optimism. The detailed plans are now in place, the funding is apparently on the way - now the challenge turns to implementation and to engaging and supporting civil society to also play its role.

Further information:

    * National HIV and AIDS Strategic Framework 2006-2010
    * National HIV/AIDS/STI/TB Monitoring & Evaluation Plan 2006-2010
    * Joint United Nations Programme of Support on AIDS 2007-2010
    * Joint Financing Agreement Speech, 9 March 2006

[These documents will be made available shortly on the Partners Zambia eForum and website: www.healthdev.org/partnerszambia]

Nadine Ferris France - HDN

World Diabetes Day (14 November): Caring for children and adolescents with diabetes

World Diabetes Day (14 November): Caring for children and adolescents with diabetes

The theme of this year's World Diabetes Day (14 November) is diabetes in children and adolescents. The global awareness campaign aims to bring the spot light on diabetes and highlight the message that no child should die of diabetes. It also aims to increase awareness in parents, caregivers, teachers, health care professionals, politicians and the common public regarding diabetes.

World Diabetes Day (www.worlddiabetesday.org) is observed every year on November 14, because this day marks the birthday of Frederick Banting, who was credited with discovering insulin some 87 years ago. This day was first introduced in 1991 by the International Diabetes Federation (IDF) and the World Health Organization (WHO), in response to the alarming rise in diabetes around the world. In 2007, the United Nations made the day an official UN world day after the passage of the United Nations World Diabetes Day Resolution in December 2006. The UN recognized that diabetes is increasing at an epidemic rate and is affecting people of all ages.

Diabetes is one of the most common chronic conditions to affect children. It can strike children of any age-- even toddlers and babies. If not detected early enough in a child, diabetes can be fatal or it may result in serio
us brain damage. Yet diabetes in a child is often completely overlooked: it is often misdiagnosed as the flu or is not diagnosed at all.

In both urban and rural areas, diabetes in children and adolescents often does not get diagnosed in time. The reasons for this are manifold-- lack of education / awareness of the symptoms of this condition, lack of proper care, girl child stigma and poverty.

"Early diagnosis of diabetes in children is very poor in rural areas and some of them die because of it, in the absence of timely diagnosis and /or treatment, which is pretty shameful for us. Therefore the government should strengthen its rural healthcare services for early diagnosis and proper treatment /care of diabetes in children and adolescents" said Professor Dr CS Yajnik, Director, Diabetes Unit, King Edward Memorial Hospital , Pune , India .

Every parent, school teacher, school nurse, doctor and others involved in the care of children should be familiar with the warning signs or symptoms of diabetes which could be any one or more of the following:-- frequent urination, excessive thirst, increased hunger, weight loss, tiredness, lack of concentration, blurred vision, vomiting and stomach pain. In children with Type-2 diabetes these symptoms may be mild or absent.

Type-1 diabetes is an auto-immune disease that cannot be prevented. Globally, it is the most common form of diabetes in children, affecting around 500,000 children under 15 years of age. Finland , Sweden and Norway have the highest incidence rates for Type-1 diabetes in children. However, as a result of increasing childhood obesity and sedentary lifestyles, Type-2 diabetes is also increasing at a very fast pace in children and adolescents. In some countries, like Japan , Type- 2 diabetes has become more common in children than Type-1.

Every day more than 200 children are diagnosed with Type-1 diabetes, requiring them to take multiple daily insulin shots and monitor the glucose levels in their blood. This type of diabetes is increasing yearly at the rate of 3% amongst children and is rising even faster in pre-school children at the rate of 5% per year. Diabetic Ketoacidosis (DKA), a build-up of excess acids in the body as a result of uncontrolled diabetes, is a major cause of death in children with Type-1 diabetes. DKA can be prevented with early diagnosis and proper medical care.

Life for children living with Type-1 diabetes, in the developing world, is bleak indeed. About 75,000 children in the low-income and lower-middle income countries are living with diabetes in desperate circumstances. These children need life-saving insulin to survive. Many are in need of monitoring equipment, test strips and proper guidance to manage their condition in order to avoid the life-threatening complications associated with diabetes. A child's access to appropriate medication and care should be a right and not a privilege.

"A comprehensive approach that addresses diabetes risk factors is needed. Researchers have found that societal influences on teenage boys and girls can affect their diabetes, and that in most cases girls suffer more from these influences," said Dr Sonia Kakkar, a Delhi based diabetes specialist.

Type- 2 diabetes affects children in both developed and developing countries and is becoming a global public health issue with potentially serious outcomes.

It has been reported in children as young as eight years and now exists even in those who were previously thought not to be at risk. In native and aboriginal communities in the United States , Canada and Australia at least 1 in every 100 youth has diabetes. In some communities, this ratio is 1 in every 25. Global studies have shown that Type- 2 diabetes can be prevented by enabling individuals to lose 7-10% of their body weight, and by increasing their physical activity to a modest level.

"The stark reality is that many children in developing countries die soon after diagnosis," said Dr Jean-Claude Mbanya, President-Elect of the International Diabetes Federation (IDF), in a press release issued by IDF. Dr Mbanya further said, "It has been 87 years since the discovery of insulin, yet many of the world's most vulnerable citizens, including many children, die needlessly because of lack of access to this essential drug. This is a global shame. We owe it to future generations to address this issue now."

According to the International Diabetes Federation, "In many developing countries, particularly in Sub-Saharan Africa and some parts of Asia , life-saving diabetes medication and monitoring equipment is often unavailable or unaffordable. As a result, many children with diabetes die soon after diagnosis, or have a quality of life, and they develop the devastating complications of the disease early."

In order to support some of these children, the IDF created its Life for a Child Program in 2001. The program, which is operated in partnership with Diabetes Australia-NSW and HOPE worldwide, currently supports a total of 1000 children in Azerbaijan, Bolivia, The Democratic Republic of Congo, Ecuador, Fiji, India, Mali, Nepal, Nigeria, Papua New Guinea, The Philippines, Rwanda, Sri Lanka, Sudan, The United Republic of Tanzania, Uzbekistan and Zimbabwe.

Although significant activities have been initiated in the past few years to improve health responses to diabetes, efforts are still inadequate, weak and fragmented. Progress is impeded by a public health system that places a higher priority on communicable diseases and maternal and child health services and by a private health system driven by curative medicine. However, a comprehensive health response to diabetes that addresses prevention, treatment, care and support needs for people with diabetes, needs more advocacy and partnership with different agencies that can bring in the desired changes in the life of every person living with diabetes.

IDF asks everyone around the world to help bring diabetes to light and to affect change to improve care for people living with diabetes. Find out more at www.worlddiabetesday.org


Amit Dwivedi
(The author is a Special Correspondent to Citizen News Service (CNS). Email: amit@citizen-news.org)

Published in
Asian Tribune, Thailand/ Sri Lanka
Gambia News, Gambia
News Track India, Delhi
Ghana News, Accra, Ghana
News Blaze, USA
Thai Indian News, Bangkok, Thailand
Op-Ed News (OEN), UK
Daiji-World, Maharashtra
My News, Delhi
News from Bangladesh, Dhaka, Bangladesh
News Tin
Two Circles
Citizen News Service (CNS)
Madhumeh
Bihar and Jharkhand News Service (BJNS)
Bihar Times, Patna, Bihar
Pakistan Post, Karachi, Pakistan
Northern News Lines, Chandigarh
Media for Freedom, Kathmandu, Nepal
Medical News India
The Zimbabwe Guardian, Harare, Zimbabwe
Banderas News, Mexico
Topix
Day Life
Scoop Independent News, New Zealand
Med-India.com
Assam Times, Guwahati, Assam
Kerala News, Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala
Mangalorean Times, Mangalore, Karnataka
Darjeeling Times, Darjeeling, West Bengal
Howrah News Service (HNS), West Bengal

Obama and Mayawati: a Comparison in Contrast

Obama and Mayawati: a Comparison in Contrast
SR Darapuri

It will be apt to mention in the beginning that a comparison between Obama and Mayawati (Dalit woman Chief Minister of UP state in India) is not very appropriate because there is a world of difference between their personalities and deeds. But some over enthusiastic followers of Mayawati have started comparing them and are spreading the dictum that "if Obama can do it why cannot she?" They have started projecting her as the future Prime Minister of India. As such it becomes necessary to make an attempt to make a comparison between Obama and Mayawati.

The first point of comparison between Obama and Mayawati is their social background. Obama is an African-American. His father was black and his mother was white. Mayawati's both parents are dalits. But it is pertinent to note that during his electioneering he nowhere used his black identity to influence his voters. Throughout his election campaign he spoke about his policies and plans whereas in the case of Mayawati she has never spoken about her policies and plans. On the other hand her dalit identity is the starting point of her politics for emotional exploitation of dalits.


The second point of comparison between Obama and Mayawati is their ability to mobilize fund for the party. Obama through small contributions raised a party fund to the tune of $650 millions but he deposited it in the party fund account and used it for electioneering. Mayawati also raised her property to the tune of Rs. 520 millions up to 2007 and further added Rs. 600 millions during 2007-08. But she did not deposit this amount in party fund account. Rather she deposited it in her personal and her family member's accounts. There are also allegations of selling MLA's and MP's tickets at election time at competitive rates. It is worth mentioning that CBI has already prepared a charge sheet against her for amassing personal property worth Rs. 300 millions beyond her known sources of income.

The third point of comparison between Obama and Mayawati concerns their policies and plans. As we know Obama fought the election on the plank of "Need of change for America" and has won it with this promise. He has promised to take America out of financial crises and reduce unemployment. As regards Mayawati she has never made any promise to solve any public problem. In fact she does not have any such plan or program to solve the public problems like poverty, unemployment, lack of health infrastructure, drinking water, housing and illiteracy etc.

The fourth point of comparison between Obama and Mayawati is their pursuit of political power. Obama has been elected as the most powerful President of the oldest democracy of the world. Mayawati has also been elected for the fourth time as the Chief Minister of the most populous state (Uttar Pardesh) of India. Obama has promised to use the political power for solving the problems facing the U.S. people whereas Mayawati has been accused of using it for self aggrandizement. Dr. Ambedkar had remarked that political power should be used for social progress. But Mayawati lacks such inclination even in the case of dalits who are her prime constituency. As a result of it the dalits of U.P. continue to be behind the dalits of all other states of India except that of Bihar and Orissa. In spite of her occupying the Chief Ministership for the fourth time U.P. continues to suffer from under industrialization and over all backwardness. As such she can be held responsible for the backwardness of U.P. as well as that of U.P.dalits to a good extent. According to one study U.P. has suffered regression during the last decade. It is noticeable that Mayawati has been in power since 1995 with some breaks in between.

The next point of comparison between Obama and Mayawati can be in respect of psychological impact of their victory on their voters. In case of Obama his victory has exhilarated Blacks, Minorities and Whites also to good extent. In case of Mayawati dalits excluding intellectual section thereof and muscleman and moneyed men of higher castes are only exhilarated because the latter are especially the main beneficiaries of her position. Dalits have only the psychological satisfaction of having a Chief Minister of their own caste. They are totally deprived of all the material gains of power on account of corrupt and inefficient administration being run by Mayawati. Minorities, mainly the Muslims are highly skeptical about Mayawati because in her pursuit of political power she can make alliance with their staunch opponent and a communal party like B.J.P. as she had done thrice in the past.

From a brief comparison between Obama and Mayawati it becomes evident that it is not very appropriate because there is a world of difference between their personalities and deeds. Rather it can be said to be a comparison in contrast. Even then if admirers of Mayawati are so anxious to make a comparison they should look for qualities like a vision, an urge for change, impeccable integrity and inclination to use political power for social progresses as exemplified in Obama. They must display mental honesty and proper courage to criticize her for her personal greed to amass wealth, lack of vision and unprincipled pursuit of power. She may also be dissuaded from wasting public money in creating memorials and installing her own statues in an effort to immortalize her. People are immortalized by their noble deeds and not by their statue. Obama is to be judged in the near future but Mayawati has already been judged.

SR Darapuri
(The author is a retired Inspector General (IG) Police, Government of India. Email: srdarapuri@yahoo.co.in)

Published in
Khabar Express, Bikaner, Rajasthan
Bihar and Jharkhand News Service (BJNS)
Northern News Lines, Chandigarh
Ghana News, Accra, Ghana
Thai Indian News, Bangkok, Thailand
Assam Times, Guwahati, Assam
Two Circles
News Track India, Delhi
Citizen News Service (CNS)
Bihar Times, Patna, Bihar
Media for Freedom, Kathmandu, Nepal
Dalit Liberation
The Bangladesh Today, Dhaka, Bangladesh
Counter Currents
News Blaze, USA
Asian Tribune, Bangkok, Thailand
My News, Delhi
The Seoul Times, Seoul, South Korea
News from Bangladesh, Dhaka, Bangladesh
Pakistan Post, Karachi, Pakistan
Central Chronicle, Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh
Op-Ed News (OEN), UK
URLfan.com
Truth Feeds
Kerala News, Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala
Bangladesh Daily News Service
Ambedkar Times
Howrah News Service (HNS), West Bengal

National partnership for TB care and control is shaping up in India

National partnership for TB care and control is shaping up in India

A national multi-stakeholder partnership for TB care and control is shaping up in India. Last week on 4 November 2008, representatives from a range of TB stakeholders participated in a day-long meeting at LRS Institute of Tuberculosis and Respiratory Diseases in New Delhi. The meeting was facilitated by the International Union Against Tuberculosis and Lung Disease (IUATLD, The Union)’s India Resource Center.

India ranks first in the list of 22 TB high burden countries globally with about 1/5th of the world’s TB cases. According to the World Health Organization (WHO)’s Anti Tuberculosis Drug Resistance in the World report (2008), India and China together have more than 50% of the world’s drug-resistant TB cases. India also figures high-up on the list of high-burden multi-drug resistant TB (MDR-TB) countries in the world.

However all is not that bleak – India has certainly made major strides in TB care and control, testing more than 40 million people for TB, rolling out anti-TB treatment to more than 9 million sputum-positive patients since 1997, every month more than 100,000 patients are put on Directly-Observed Treatment Short-course (DOTS) treatment, with more than 85% cure rate in sputum-positive patients, under the Revised National TB control Programme (RNTCP). However it is due to poor programme performance of DOTS that drug-resistant TB has been on an alarming rise.

“Partnerships in TB care and control is not new to India” said Dr LS Chauhan, Deputy Director General (TB), Directorate General of Health Services, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India. “Since 1995, India has forged partnerships with different sectors to improve TB programme performances” added Dr Chauhan.

“Despite of the involvement of more than 2,500 NGOs, private practitioners, 260 medical colleges and 110 corporate sector hospitals in the RNTCP, the contribution of the TB programme is not at the desired level” said Dr Chauhan, clearly articulating the need that a lot more needs to be done to improve TB programme performance in India.

“There is a need now for close coordination and clear communication while working together to face the challenge of including those who are currently outside the reach of the public health system" said Dr Chauhan. “There is not enough coordination between different TB stakeholders at the district or state level, and not regular coordination at the national level” remarked Dr Chauhan.

Dr Chauhan also said that “the RNTCP programme cannot document every best practice or challenges faced at the grassroots in TB care and control, so other people need to take leadership and come forward”. These voices of the frontline workers in TB care and control need to be well documented and ‘heard’ in order to inform the policy makers for a desired change to improve TB programme performance.

Recent reports have identified programmatic challenges impeding TB responses in India that include limited community awareness, sub-optimal community participation and sense of ownership, emerging challenges of TB-HIV co-infection and drug-resistant-TB management and limited access to quality TB care for the hard to reach, marginalized and vulnerable populations.

“8 million new TB cases diagnosed every year and two TB deaths take place every 3 minutes in India” said Professor (Dr) D Behera, Director, LRS Institute of Tuberculosis and Respiratory Diseases, New Delhi. “Just providing anti-TB treatment is not sufficient, treatment is interrupted due to poverty, unemployment, etc” added Dr Behera.

“At USAID, partnerships are the way to do business. Partnerships enhance efficiency and effectiveness, rational division of labour, maximize synergy” said Robin Mardeusz from the United States Agency for International Development (USAID). Robin highlighted one of the major benefits of the partnerships in providing multi-action innovative solutions. USAID has supported the secretariat of the national partnership for TB care and control to be hosted by The Union through a World Vision grant.

Another civil society partnership on TB which exists in India since March 2007 to complement India’s RNTCP is the NGO TB Consortium which includes eight major civil society organizations contributing to TB care and control: Adventist Development Relief Agency (ADRA), Damien Foundation India Trust (DFIT), German Leprosy and TB Relief Association (GLRA) , LEPRA Society , PATH India , Project Concern International (PCI) India , TB Alert India and World Vision India.

One clear mandate of an effective and genuine partnership for TB care and control should be to help strengthen mechanisms for equitable access to information and meaningful participation, particularly of those undergoing anti-TB treatment, or those who have successfully completed their anti-TB treatment or those who are at increased risk of TB including people living with HIV (PLHIV). Without documenting these voices of the affected communities so that the best practices and challenges both inform the national TB programmes so as to improve the programme performances, India will fail to achieve the targets for TB prevention, treatment and care.

Another major mandate of such a partnership should be to radically scale up communications and advocacy to implement the Patients' Charter for Tuberculosis Care, so that affected communities can use the Patients' Charter to raise awareness and consciousness about the rights and responsibilities of people with TB, to strive towards achieving International Standards for Tuberculosis Care across the country.

How complementing will be the NGO TB Consortium to the National Partnership for TB Care and Control, is yet to be seen. Also how we build or help strengthen high quality and reliable platforms for information exchange, genuine dialogue and advocacy on TB/HIV issues, keeping the voices of the affected communities at the centre of such discourses, will be a daunting challenge.

May be it is time to step out of our organizational entities and join hands for better synergy to bring the affected communities in the centre of TB/HIV response and help India achieve the TB prevention, treatment and care targets it has set out for.

Published in: Northern News Lines (Chandigarh, India); Two Circles; My News (Delhi, India); News Blaze (USA); HealthDev.net; Ghana News (Accra, Ghana); Truth Feeds; Op-Ed News (OEN); Congo News; Media for Freedom (Kathmandu, Nepal); Bihar and Jharkhand News Service (BJNS); Bihar Times (Patna, Bihar); Citizen News Service (CNS); News Track India (Delhi, India); The Seoul Times (Seoul, South Korea); Howrah News Service (HNS), West Bengal

Climate change is impeding agricultural production in Uttar Pradesh

Climate change is impeding agricultural production in Uttar Pradesh

During the last one decade Uttar Pradesh has been witness to many climatic changes. Eastern Uttar Pradesh has faced severe floods, while Bundelkhand region has faced one of the worst famines of the last decade. Thus, the impact of climate change has adversely affected agricultural production resulting in huge loss of paddy and corn crops in eastern districts and regional crops in Bundelkhand. Climate-related disasters have brought widespread misery and huge economic losses to Uttar Pradesh, adversely affecting public health, food security, agriculture, water resources and biodiversity in the state.

Floods are the most common annual occurrences in Uttar Pradesh, affecting one or the other part of the state; the most affected being the districts of the eastern U.P.and terai region.

Agriculture in India is very much weather-dependent. It is ironic, then, that a significant percentage of greenhouse-gas emission-come from agriculture. Fossil-fuel intensive agriculture is contributing to the creation of the unpredictable weather conditions which all farmers will need to battle in the not so distant future.

Scientists believe that the fluctuating weather conditions in a state suggest that the state is reeling under climatic chaos. For more than a decade now, the state has been experiencing contrasting extreme weather conditions. Agriculture has been worst affected in Uttar Pradesh by these climatic changes. . A little decrease in temperatures can reduce the production of wheat crops, but help in the growth of paddy. Such changes may often tilt the farmers towards growing one crop at the expense of the other. This would lead to imbalances in crop production.

According to the 2001 census, 62.12 percent of the state’s total workers are engaged in agriculture. UP contributes on an average 21 percent to the national production of foodgrain. With an average annual food grain production of about 42.7 million tons and per capita production of 234 kg, U.P. ranks third highest among major states, and is considered to be a food grain surplus state. Yet the plight of farmers is far from satisfactory.

“Government and development organizations have tried to deal with the situation, but their initiatives have been more relief oriented than solution oriented. Local people have devised their own ways and means to deal with the situation. Their methods are inherently scientific and require no external help or support. These region specific techniques have shaped people’s lifestyles in these regions and strengthened their adaptive capacities,” said Prof. (Dr) Shiraj A Wajih, President, Gorakhpur Environmental Action Group.

According to a ‘Gorakhpur Environmental Action Group, GEAG (www.geagindia.org)’ survey “U.P.’s agriculture is characterized by very small size of land holdings; around 90 percent of the farmers in the state are small and marginal farmers. Some 73.8 percent of the total operational holdings in the state are marginal (below 1.0 ha) and another 15.5 percent holdings are small (between 1 and 2 ha). Due to the preponderance of the small holdings cropping pattern, U.P. agriculture is still largely subsistence oriented.”

He further said that, “We need to strengthen our capacities and capabilities to deal with climatic changes, civil society should be more responsible and sensitive towards nature. Government should make interdepartmental approach and farmer friendly policies. It should not jeopardize agricultural growth in favour of corporate interests. Being one of the most populous geographically diverse state of India , U.P. is more prone to climatic changes.”

In the Bundelkhand area, with its high levels of poverty, many small and marginal farmers are indebted both to moneylenders and government banks. As the weather gets hotter, the chances of paying back loans become difficult, leading to stress and in some extreme cases, suicides. The growing water scarcity poses further problems of survival to people and animals alike. Already there have been reports of cattle deaths due to water scarcity in the district. In recent years, the water level has gone down significantly.

The ill effects of climate change can also be seen on women farmers, especially poor women farmers because of their low social and economic status. They also have lesser accessibility to livelihood resources and land holdings.

There is a serious danger of climatic changes (in the form of severe droughts, floods, intense rainfall, and storms) undermining development programmes and millennium development goals aimed at reducing poverty.

Currently India is spending 2.5% of its total GDP on measures to control the adverse impact of climatic change, which is a big amount for any developing nation. sThe zeal of rapid industrialization, deforestation and wilful consumption of natural resources is likely to make the situation worse. Policy makers at the state, regional and national level should take a serious view of the economic, agricultural, health-related and environmental impacts of climate changes.

Amit Dwivedi

(The author is a Special Correspondent to Citizen News Service (CNS). Email: amit@citizen-news.org, website: www.Citizen-News.org)

Published in
Central Chronicle, Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh
Asian Tribune, Bangkok, Thailand
The Nation, Dhaka, Bangladesh
Op-Ed News (OEN), UK
Silo-Breaker news
My News, Delhi
Congo News
News Blaze, USA
Ghana News, Accra, Ghana
Booksville
The Zimbabwe Guardian, Harare, Zimbabwe
Pakistan Post, Karachi, Pakistan
Carbon-Based News, USA
Two Circles, USA
Citizen News Service (CNS)
Truth News Feeds
Northern News Lines, Chandigarh
Uttar Pradesh News
Media for Freedom, Kathmandu, Nepal
Kerala News, Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala
News Track India, Delhi
Yahoo! Buzz News
Bihar Times, Patna, Bihar
Digg.com
Banderas News, Mexico
Scoop Independent News, New Zealand
Bihar and Jharkhand News Service (BJNS)
The Seoul Times, Seoul, South Korea
Climate Ark
Green State
Assam Times, Guwahati, Assam
Water Conserve News
Howrah News Service (HNS), West Bengal

REPORT-from-the-Frontlines: Kosi flood affected Murliganj (Bihar)

REPORT-from-the-Frontlines:
Kosi flood affected Murliganj (Bihar)


Dr Sandeep Pandey

Asha Parivar and
National Alliance of People's Movements (NAPM)

Report from visit to Kosi flood affected Murliganj Block of Madhepura Dist. in Bihar on 31st October and 1st November, 2008

Mahendra Yadav and his team of Asha Parivar is stationed in Babhangama, 15 kms. from Muraliganj Block headquarters of Madhepura Dist. of Bihar for over two months now to carry out relief operations and help people access relief from government schemes. Muraliganj is 80 kms. from Katihar railway station.

The salient points that emerged from my meeting with Asha Parivar and NAPM volunteers as well as from interaction with flood victims during a open debate organized by Mahendra on 1st November, 2008 at Muraliganj which was attended by 600-700 people are:

(1) People are being forced to vacate camps and mega camps as the government wants to abdicate its responsibility towards flood victims. While in camps the government has to take full responsibility of the affected people, including providing them food, health care, education to children, etc.

(2) The agricultural fields from which water is receding is now covered with various levels of sand. It is not cultivable until the sand is removed. On the other hand earth had been dug deep at several spots because of sharp water current. It'll take a year or two before people can start recultivating their fields.

(3) The farmers will need agricultural tools, seeds, fertilizers, etc., to start agriculture again. The question of how the sharecropper, who doesn't officially hold any land but undertook major part of agricultural activity, will receive compensation still needs to be addressed. Similarly other artisans will need their tools.

(4) People also need compensation for dead/lost cattle. The cattle which remain with the people are facing problem in being fed. The hay is all wet and government supply is unreliable because of rampant corruption.

(5) Health care facilities are poor. People have to often rush to private practitioners when the government system is not able to attend to them. There have been number of casualities due to negligence.

(6) All educational activity is standstill. It needs to begin.

(7) The compensation of Rs. 2250 in cash and one quintal of foodgrains is not being distributed honestly. At some places only 50-70 kgs. of foodgrains are being given. If somebody's name doesn't figure in APL or BPL lists, they are being denied relief.

(8) People should be encouraged to use RTI to access benefits flowing through various routine government schemes as well as those announced specially for flood victims.

Suggestions to Government:
-------------------------
(1) Make NREGS provision for 365 days for the next 1-2 years for flood affected areas of five districts affected by Kosi. People should be allowed to claim wages under NREGS for working to rebuild their own houses and for removing sand from their fields. People may have to be invited from other parts of Bihar and even other poorer states to remove sands from the fields under NREGS.

(2) PDS benefits to be extended to all families under BPL category. Supplies should be given on the basis of per member in family rather than per family. People need kerosene for lighting lamps in the night so that they can be saved from snake bites.

(3) Special package for reconstruction of Kosi flood affected area should be given by Central Government which should aim to help people get onto their feet. Various employment generation schemes will have to be implemented. The unemployed educated youth in this area should be provided with jobs.

(4) All flood affected families should be provided one Indira Awas housing.

Appeal to Civil Society:
------------------------
(1) Volunteers needed, esp. doctors, veterinary doctors and teachers.

(2) Asha Parivar has decided to reach out to 10,000 families. Blankets are needed for these families.

(3) Asha Parivar has decided to provide alternative housing at the cost of Rs. 700 per house to 1000 families. Funds needed for this.

(4) Asha Parivar needs volunteers from 10th November to 30th November for carrying out a survey.

(5) Equipments needed - computers, laptops, printer, modem and digital camera.

(6) One volunteer is needed who can take care of bookkeeping/accounts.

(7) Medicines needed.

(8) Cattle feed needed.

Any relief material from anywhere in India should be booked for railway station of Katihar (NF Railway) and the 'bilty' (to claim the material from the railways) should be sent to Mahendra Yadav at the address: Asha Parivar, c/o Paramount School, Babhangama, Muraliganj Block, Dist. Madhepura, Mobile: 9973936658.

Any financial contributions may be sent in the name of 'Asha' to: Vallabhacharya Pandey, Village Bhandaha Kalan, Post Kaithi, Varanasi-221116, Ph: (0542) 2618201, 2618301, 2618401, Mobile : 9415256848, ashakashi@gmail.com

For more information, please contact:
------------------------------------

Dr Sandeep Pandey
Asha Parivar and
National Alliance of People's Movements (NAPM)
Phone: 0522 2347365
Email: ashaashram@yahoo.com

With proper care, adolescents with diabetes can lead full and healthy lives

With proper care, adolescents with diabetes can lead full and healthy lives

Diabetes has a unique impact on the lives of adolescents and requires constant monitoring of blood sugar levels, medication and balancing the effects of food and activity. With careful management by diabetologists, nutritionists, and psychologists, and with support from parents, these young people can lead full and healthy lives. They can participate in sports and compete for jobs as effectively as those adolescents without diabetes.

The International Diabetes Federation (IDF)’s World Diabetes Day campaign focuses this year on children and adolescents with diabetes. According to IDF, children and adolescents with diabetes face a lifetime of living with a disease that poses peculiar challenges for them. These struggles include higher insulin insensitivity linked to puberty, rapid behavioural changes, increased risk of depression, anxiety, and low self-esteem.

According to IDF, globally there are 500,000 children under 15 years of age, type 1 diabetes. Of these children, more than a quarter live in South East Asia. Type 2 diabetes is increasing in children worldwide, with some as young as 8 years of age. Many of them are from ethnic groups known to be a high risk of type 2 diabetes. Type 2 diabetes is increasing rapidly in children in both developed and developing countries. The majority of children (85%) with type 2 diabetes are overweight or obese at the time of diagnosis.

Type 2 diabetes in young people severely increases the risks of complications such as heart disease at an early age. This can have serious consequences on the child’s health. IDF recommends that provisions be made to deliver the best possible care, prevent long-term complications, and promote further research in order to reach a better understanding of the condition. Type 2 diabetes in children and adolescents, (as also in adults) is due to a combination of insensitivity to insulin and relative failure of beta-cell secretion. There are a number of genetic and environmental risk factors for insensitivity to insulin and limited beta-cell reserves, including ethnicity, obesity, sedentary lifestyle, family history of type 2 diabetes, puberty, low birth weight, exposure to diabetes in the uterus, and female gender. There is ample evidence that certain ethnic groups have greater susceptibility to diabetes than others. According to IDF, "there are currently over 250 million people with diabetes; with approximately 120 million of them in the developing world. Increased urbanisation, rapid cultural and social changes, unhealthy lifestyles and behavioural patterns mean that 80% of global diabetes cases are predicted to occur in low and middle income countries."

"Diabetes is part of a larger global epidemic of non-communicable diseases. Because these diseases share many risk factors, policies that encourage healthy eating and active living will prevent not only type 2 diabetes, but also obesity, cardiovascular disease (CVD), chronic respiratory illnesses, and diet-related cancers. An integrated system can maximize disease prevention while avoiding the need to develop separate courses of action. Strategies proposed here are prioritized according to their ability to be aligned and integrated into a comprehensive movement that addresses all non-communicable diseases," said Dr Anoop Misra, Director and Head, Department of Diabetes and Metabolic Diseases, Fortis Hospitals, New Delhi and NOIDA.

He further said that, "Nutrition plays a very important role in the management of diabetes among adolescents and others. Proper nutritional intake of high fibrous diet with lots of fruits and vegetables, wholesome grain/cereal intake, whole pulses, and a low intake of refined cereals, calorie dense foods, saturated fats, oily/ fried / fatty foods needs to be promoted."

"In growing children and adolescents, allowance must be made of adequate calories and balanced nutrition. Along with proper nutrition, it is very important to encourage daily physical activity" said Dr Misra.

There is a need to spread the awareness regarding diabetes and the factors that could make the adolescents at a high risk for the onset of type 2 diabetes. Those children and adolescents who have a parent or sibling living with type 2 diabetes, should take extra care. They need to strictly maintain normal weight, play or do some aerobic exercises at least 30 minutes a day, take plenty of fruits and vegetables, and avoid junk food.

"In both urban and rural areas, diabetes in poor children and adolescents does not get diagnosed in time. There could be several reasons for this like lack of education, no proper care, girl child stigma and poverty," said Dr. Sonia Kakkar, a Delhi based doctor. She further said that "though diabetes action has been initiated, efforts are weak and fragmented. Progress is impeded by a health system that places a higher priority on communicable diseases and maternal and child health services and by a private health system driven by curative medicine. However, prevention is cost-effective and should be the main focus."

A comprehensive approach that addresses type 2 diabetes risk factors is needed. Harnessing positive aspects of globalization - increased information flow, improved technology, and innovation - via international collaboration is crucial. In India, a country with limited health resources, an approach that draws on many sectors - including the private sector - can ensure successful implementation of the diabetes care programme for adolescents.

Amit Dwivedi
(The author is a Special Correspondent to Citizen News Service (CNS). Email: amit@citizen-news.org)


Published in
Asian Tribune, Bangkok, Thailand
Banderas News, Mexico
Standard Times, Sierra Leone
Northern News Lines, Chandigarh
Two Circles
Assam Times, Guwahati, Assam
Citizen News Service (CNS)
Ghana News, Accra, Ghana
Media for Freedom, Kathmandu, Nepal
Bihar and Jharkhand News Service (BJNS)
Bihar Times, Patna, Bihar
Madhumeh
News Medical.net, Australia
News Blaze, USA
My News, Delhi
Yahoo! Buzz News

Truth Feeds
Op-Ed News (OEN), UK
Central Chronicle, Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh
Chris Floyd News
The Zimbabwe Guardian, Harare, Zimbabwe

Global Recession: One of the Several Crises facing Human Society

Global Recession: One of the Several Crises facing Human Society

Dr Rahul Pandey

I do not remember witnessing this kind of global panic in my lifetime. Probably the twin towers crash generated a reaction of similar magnitude as the recent financial meltdown and recession.

Among others, a lot of well off people are going to be directly affected by the current financial crisis, hence these high decibel alarm bells. Significant market values of high profile companies have been wiped out, rich individuals who invest actively in stock market have suffered devaluation, many companies have begun to fire employees and cut costs, and as bigger companies face slowdown, their smaller suppliers face greater threat to survival. Consumers have begun to tighten spending and fears of recession giving way to depression are already stalking. Though a lot has been written and a lot is yet to be written about this turmoil, my purpose here is to draw up its deeper structural links and paint the broader picture by viewing it together with other crises facing the human society.

This global financial crisis, expected to last longer than most of us hope, joins the other four equally global and longer lasting crises that humanity has been facing since at least a few decades now. The global terrorism and inter-community conflicts. The global warming and unsustainable exploitation of natural resources. Sustaining, if not rising, levels of poverty, unemployment and inequality between and within nations. And the high levels of psychological stress that many of us bear due to modern work and life styles. These crises span all domains of human society – economic, cultural, ecological, and psychological. I will merely remind here that all these phenomena are eventually linked to the structure of the current dominant economic system that man has designed. And the political system that supports it. Let us briefly look at each of these crises in turn.

First, that the current financial meltdown and accompanying economic recession is a direct outcome of undisciplined financial transactions of the free market is not in doubt. The utterly unregulated derivatives and other speculation driven markets combined with large scale lending and borrowing choked the system to the point of no return. Even the temporary fuel and food inflation that preceded and overlapped with the general recession was at least partially due to unregulated speculation and hoarding.

Second, the widespread international terrorism is directly linked to the US-led global wars and can be traced back to its ambitions of strengthening its economic and military control of the globe. While the connection with the economic system is not direct, the desperation of America and its allies for control over global oil reserves and other natural resources did play a role in these conflicts. Control of these resources has been crucial to sustain the high growth economic activities and ultra consumerist lifestyles that are integral to the free capital market driven economies.

Third, it is now well accepted by everyone but a few self-delusory beings that the global warming and climate change is the direct consequence of human-induced rapid burning of fossil fuels. This unsustainable rate of burning has been done to meet the requirement of high growing economies and consumerist lifestyles. As the environmental externalities were not valued by the market, digging the fossil fuels, though ecologically disastrous, made economic sense. It enabled the producers to control energy and material costs and the well off consumers to enjoy the luxuries of energy intensive living like comfortable housing, private transport, and many lavish consumptions.

Fourth, though it is not a widely agreed effect, there is a link between the current economic paradigm and economic inequality and poverty. As average income of all economic organizations is roughly equivalent to average wage of all working people, a few can draw very high salaries only at the expense of the vast majority drawing less than average. A way of dealing with such glaring inequality and consequent discontentment has been to sustain a multi-layered and widely distributed income among people. Such multiple layers are created in the form of several hierarchies of employees with differential wage rates, earning differences between companies, between various economic activities, and between countries and geographies. Although such deep economic stratification of society helps in diffusing mass mobilization of discontent and creating cushion of managers, it also reinforces inequality and poverty. Casual wage labourers commonly seen working on farms, construction sites, small and medium factories, small road-side shops, as ragpickers and as private help in rich and middle-class households in the developing countries are examples of the most deprived economic classes in capitalist societies. Their numbers are large but their incomes are far less than prevailing average prices of commodities including several essential ones. A terribly divided lot, they try to survive on the fringes by cutting into their families’ essential needs like nutritious food, adequate clothes, shelter, hygienic surrounding, access to basic healthcare, and education of children.

Fifth, even the economically well off individuals in today’s society suffer from severe levels of psychological stress and related psychosomatic disorders. The most evident proof of this is the rising markets for pharmaceutical products on the one hand, and a variety of psycho-religious and stress relieving services on the other. The latter kind of services are offered by both professional trainers and religious, semi-religious and spiritual healers. The following of these sects has increased phenomenally among high earning individuals leading stressed work, family and social lives. It is not difficult to see that meaningless work roles and stressful working hours in the corporate sector combined with rapid paced consumption driven social life is at the core of most of our psychological problems. It is also not difficult to see that this is integral to the current economic system.

All the above examples of crises are meant to merely restate the fact that they are symptoms of the economic system that is predominantly driven by materialistic growth, consumption and greed. This system has proved to be too cruel and insensitive.

A major correction is therefore needed in this system to move towards a more humane and eco-friendly one. Such a change may of course not come through during the current course of events. Whether and when it occurs will depend on the interplay of political forces. One thing is certain: the battles on the global political arena will intensify and become messy. Capitalist lobbies will use all their financial muscle to try and retain as much autonomy as possible. Religious-Right groups will raise the bogey of 'moral values' and demand greater fundamentalist control over behaviour of organizations and people. Some on the Left will ask for greater authority of the State over people.

Saner voices will be of those who will demand real and greater democratic rights to the ordinary people. Democratic structures and channels that ensure even the economically weakest a proportionate say in the process of decisions and policies alone can guarantee economic, ecological, cultural and psychological contentment for all. We are still far behind such real democracy. But that is the way to move.

Dr Rahul Pandey

The author is a former faculty member of Indian Institute of Technology (IIT) Bombay and Indian Institute of Management (IIM) Lucknow, and is currently a member of a start up venture that develops mathematical models for planning and policy analysis. His areas of interest include mathematical modeling, biological evolution, physics, development and environment, sustainable economics and industry, and social change. He can be contacted at rahulanjula@gmail.com

Published in
Central Chronicle, Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh
Thai Indian News, Bangkok, Thailand
Asian Tribune, Bangkok, Thailand
The Zimbabwe Guardian, Harare, Zimbabwe
News Track India, Delhi
Ghana News, Accra, Ghana
Northern News Lines, Chandigarh
Pakistan Post, Karachi, Pakistan
Stock Market One
Peaceful Burma News, Myanmar
Media for Freedom, Kathmandu, Nepal
Bihar Times, Patna, Bihar
Citizen News Service (CNS)
Bihar and Jharkhand News Service (BJNS)
Two Circles
Banderas News, Mexico
Standard Times, Sierra Leone
News Medical.net, Australia
The Seoul Times, Seoul, South Korea
Red Tram International
News Blaze, USA
My News, Delhi
The Liberian Journal, Liberia
The Jamaica Star, Jamaica
Conservative Revolutionary American Party
IIM Alumni CollectiveX
Truth Feeds, USA
Op-Ed News (OEN), UK
The Bangladesh Today, Dhaka, Bangladesh
Planet Powai Community News, Mumbai, Maharashtra
Populum News

Ireland, MDGs and health: A drop in the ocean or a real contribution?

Photo by A. BlightHealth Dialogues: Ireland, MDGs and health: A drop in the ocean or a real contribution

Irish Forum for Global Health

*****************************

The Irish Forum for Global Health launched its new series of ‘Health Dialogues’ on 16th June 2010, bringing together over 30 participants from various backgrounds including health and development-related international NGOs, the health service, staff and students in higher education and research institutions, and others interested in global health.

Dr Diarmuid O’Donovan, Chair of the Irish Forum for Global Health, opened the session and reported back on the recent EU Conference on Global Health held in Brussels in June 2010. He highlighted the conclusions on the EU role in global health that were reached during the Council of the European Union meeting in May 2010 and that will have a significant impact on global health in the years to come.

Notable among these recommendations was the call to the EU and its Member States to agree policies and actions that prioritize their support to strengthening comprehensive health systems in partner countries. Particular concern was expressed about maternal health (MDG 5) in Sub-Saharan Africa where it was stressed that health systems should pay special attention to gender equality, women’s needs and rights, and to combating gender-based violence. The conclusions also made specific recommendations regarding support for Trade Related Intellectual Property (TRIPs), migration and the need to strengthen the links between food security, nutrition and health. Full conclusions are online at: http://onetec.be/global_health/doc/Council%20Conclusions%20Global%20Health%20May%202010.pdf

Dr Eilish McAuliffe, Director of the Centre for Global Health, Trinity College Dublin, gave an excellent presentation detailing findings from a multi-country study highlighting some of the gaps in maternal mortality in relation to health systems strengthening. Reminding participants that MDG 5 is to reduce by three quarters, between 1990 and 2015, the maternal mortality ratio, Dr McAuliffe began by outlining global action to reduce maternal mortality since 2007. She cited recent debates in the Lancet in relation to the findings regarding rates of decline in maternal mortality -for the first time a significant decline in pregnancy-related deaths from 526,300 in 1980 to 342,900 in 2008 has been reported (Hogan et al, 2010). This represents a 1.5% decline per year -to reach MDG 5 target by 2015 a decline rate of 5.5% per annum is needed. She noted that while this is the case in some countries, including some southern African countries, it is not in many others. She also pointed out that there are discrepencies in the maternal mortality rates available from different sources.

She then shared some of the key findings from a study titled ‘Health Systems Strengthening for Equity’ (HSSE) among mid-level providers (non-physician clinicians) who are responsible for the provision of Emergency Obstetric Care (EMoC) in Tanzania, Malawi and Mozambique. The study assessed factors that contribute to an enabling environment from the inputs such as staff and equipment, to the processes such as supervision, management and team-working, linking these to outcomes such as job satisfaction, performance and commitment. Findings included lack of equipment and supplies as a key constraint as well as showing many gaps in drug availability, especially in the rural hospitals. The supplies most commonly missing were not the most expensive items and yet are the ones critical to infection prevention such as sterile gloves, soap and antiseptics. Findings also indicate that very few facilities are adequately equipped to deal with eclampsia/pre-eclampsia and that the lack of oxygen seems to be a constraint to managing complications in many facilities.Other key findings include that the main providers of EmOC are mid-level providers - 80% all c-sections at district level are carried out by mid-level providers. Across all three countries mid-level providers are providing all of the Comprehensive Emergency Obstetric Care (CEmOC) signal functions(although not all providers provide all of the signal functions). Mid level providers are three times more cost-effective (Mozambique) than medical doctors and there is a high retention level. The study also highlighted the strong link between supervision and job satisfaction and the lack of structured supportive supervision in many healthcare facilities.

In drafting these findings as recommendations for interventions and further research it is clear that much can be done to improve the provision of EmOC and that addressing problems in the delivery system may have more immediate effect than addressing socio-cultural issues or attempting to manage migration. Many of the interventions required to improve care are not expensive.

Rosalyn Tamming, Head of the Health Support Unit, Concern Worldwide and Lecturer Centre at the Global Health, Trinity College Dublin, made an excellent presentation that focused on the NGO’s contribution to the health MDGs by illustrating the experience of Concern Worldwide. She began by reminding the audience of MDG 4 - to reduce by two thirds, between 1990 and 2015, the under-five mortality rate. She pointed out that under-nutrition was an underlying cause of 35% of mortality in the under 5’s and went on to describe Concern’s programmes from 1968- 2009 addressing acute malnutrition and changing over time as new products and approaches became available. Notably, she highlighted the Community Management of Acute Malnutrition (CMAM) programme, first trialed in the Dowa district of Malawi, and now endorsed by the UN as the accepted method of treating acute malnutrition in children. Prevention of malnutrition remains a key strategy for preventing child mortality and more evidence and advocacy at national and international levels is needed. Rosalyn then described child survival programmes, in particular scaling up of evidence based therapeutic and preventative interventions to reduce child mortality. Based on successful results in earlier programmes in countries such as Rwanda and Bangladesh the programme was expanded and now reaches one fifth of the children less than 5 years of age in Rwanda.

She lastly described an innovative new five-year Gates-funded programme currently being developed and implemented by Concern Worldwide in Malawi, Sierra Leone and India (Orissa State). This programme will challenge the most serious barriers to maternal neonatal child health and test original, creative and innovative ideas that will then be evaluated and scaled up if successful. She finished her presentation making the point that available, feasible interventions could prevent 6 million (63%) global child deaths at a cost of $5 billion per year. NGOs can surely do more but political will and increased resources are required.

A thought-provoking presentation given by Professor Ruairi Brugha, Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, focused on the effects of the significant rise in global finances for HIV/AIDS on health systems and the health MDGs, and specifically on how funding for HIV has impacted on non-HIV services. The presentation started with an interesting overview of the levels of funding made available in Zambia, Malawi, Ethiopia and Uganda funded by global health initiatives such as the Global Fund to Fight AIDS, TB and Malaria and the US President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief (PEPFAR) Using the Health Systems Framework as an entry point for research, findings showed there was a stagnation in staff numbers delivering services in settings in Zambia and Malawi that were scaling-up HIV services such as Antiretroviral treatment (ART) and prevention of mother to child HIV transmission (PMTCT). In 29 facilities in rural and urban areas in Zambia, there was little change in the numbers of clinical staff from 2004 to 2007, despite the large level of funds injected into health services during this time and the rapid rise in numbers of clients receiving HIV services. There was an increase in demand for services in rural areas and although staff numbers did not rise in proportion, the workload of staff in rural areas increased significantly.

There was also evidence in terms of population coverage, that numbers of clients receiving maternal and child health services were increasing in the catchment areas of facilities where HIV services were also scaling up. The research went beyond showing summary improvements in service delivery to demonstrate positive associations within facilities of scale up in HIV services (ART and PMTCT) with non HIV services – Antenatal Clinic attendance and Family Planning registration. Overall, while HIV service scale-up is occurring (MDG6), and there is some evidence that other priority services (MDG4 and 5) are benefiting, this needs to be further explored and tested through mixed methods explanatory research studies. There is clear evidence however, that rural areas are being neglected and workload is increasing, which raises concerns about staff retention and equity of access to services between rural and urban areas, which policy makers need to address.

During the open floor session chaired by Dr O’Donovan, the issue of decreased funding for health was raised. For Ireland’s contribution to the Global Fund to fight AIDS, TB and Malaria this reduction translates into a drop from €25million in 2008 to €9million in 2010. While this keeps Ireland relatively high in terms of contribution in funds per capita, reducing the contribution to the Global Fund by Ireland and other donor governments, translates into pulling back on life-saving medication (ARVs) for those in need. The impact of this is already being felt in sub-Saharan Africa.

To counter-act what was termed donor-fatigue, it was suggested that academic researchers in Ireland get more involved in advocacy, where NGOs have been active for some time. It was also suggested that institutions like the UN might consider naming those donors that have defaulted on their commitments. One participant noted that pooling money in multilateral bodies is often the most difficult to sustain support for, as attribution of successes to inputs (funding) is difficult to make and it has least traction with the general public. It was suggested that this aspect of aid is not adequately championed. Another participant suggested that there was a need to look at cost effective interventions, for example water and sanitation, given that Irish Aid health funding is unbalanced and is in decline.

There was further discussion on the purpose of the Irish Forum for Global Health (IFGH) itself as a forum. Suggestions for focus included using it to create specific targeted calls and connections between different people and groups, becoming an advocacy body and facilitating networking across sectors. It was also noted how the IFGH offered an opportunity to learn from other work going on in the area of health, such as that in the presentations given that day which can improve collaboration and learning, even in a small island such as Ireland.

The meeting ended with a short description by Dr David Weakliam, Consultant in Public Health Medicine, Department of Public Health about the recent Memorandum of Agreement signed between the Health Service Executive (HSE) and Irish Aid. The agreement, signed on 4 June 2010 by Minister of State for Overseas Development, Mr Peter Power, T.D., and Health Service Executive CEO, Professor Brendan Drumm, commits both organisations to strengthening Ireland’s overall contribution to health in the developing world by sharing expertise and promoting international best practice in support to developing countries. It will enable the HSE to make some of its experts available to provide expertise and technical advice to Irish Aid on health policy, proposals and programmes. Meanwhile, Irish Aid will assist the HSE by promoting best international practice in the HSE’s initiatives to support developing countries. HSE-Irish Aid also plan to link to other groups, including this Forum. More information about the agreement online at: http://www.dfa.ie/home/index.aspx?id=83561

Ends

(IFGH would like to thank Carlos Bruen, RCSI, for his notes that contributed to this article).

Presentations

*************

All three presentations are informative and full of useful information. They are available online at: www.globalhealth.ie under ‘presentations’.

Further reading

***************

The concerns of the impact of reduced funding on ARV treatment to HIV-positive patients was raised during the forum and one participant encouraged members to read a report recently released by MSF presenting an articulate analysis of the widening funding gap for HIV/AIDS treatment in sub-Saharan Africa (online at: http://www.msf.org/source/countries/africa/southafrica/2010/no_time_to_quit/HIV_Report_No_Time_To_Quit.pdf

Another report highlighted was Rationing Funds, Risking Lives: World Backtracks on HIV Treatment, a report produced by the International Treatment Preparedness Coalition (ITPC) in April 2010, documenting early warning signs resulting from the global pull back on AIDS commitment and funding: caps on the number of people enrolled in treatment programs, more frequent drug stock outs, and national AIDS budgets falling short (online at: http://www.itpcglobal.org/images/stories/doc/ITPC_MTT8_FINAL.pdf

******************************************

For further information about this session or the Irish Forum for Global Health, please contact: info@globalhealth.ie or visit our website at www.globalhealth.ie

If you would like to join the Irish Forum for Global Health as a member and be part of our eForum, please email to: join-globalhealth@eforums.healthdev.org

Nadine Ferris France - HDN/ IFGH